Properties
Find agent
Post property
Log in
•
Sign up
Search here
List
Shelter Island, NY land for sale
Price
$0+
$25,000+
$50,000+
$75,000+
$100,000+
$250,000+
$500,000+
Reset
Done
Size
0+ acres
2+ acres
5+ acres
10+ acres
20+ acres
50+ acres
100+ acres
Reset
Done
Tags
Types
Residential
Commercial
Agricultural
Recreational
Geography
Beachfront
Desert
Island
Lake property
Mountain
Off-grid
Resort
River property
Rural
Waterfront
Land use
Cattle ranch
Chicken farm
Dairy farm
Development
Homestead
Industrial
Investment
Mixed-use
Organic farm
Ranch
Row crop
RV lot
Small farm
Timber
Structures
A-frame house
Barn
Barndominium
Bunker
Cabin
Cottage
Farm house
House
Lodge
Mobile home
Tiny home
Workshop
Improvements
Airstrip
Fenced
Irrigated
Septic system
Solar power
Water well
Features
Cave
Creek
Mineral rights
Oil
Orchard
Pasture
Pond
Spring
Stream
Water rights
Waterfall
Wetland
Wooded
Vineyard
Activities
Borders public land
Camping
Conservation
Horse property
Fishing
Golfing
Hunting
Waterfowl
Attributes
By owner
Cheap
Distressed
Historic
New construction
Owner financed
Rent to own
Sustainable
Undeveloped
Unrestricted
Reset
Done
Format
Sale
Auction
Lease
Has house or building
Any
Yes
No
Bedrooms
Any
1+
2+
3+
4+
Square feet
Year built
Hide pending listings
Max listing age
Any
1 day
3 days
7 days
14 days
30 days
90 days
Keywords
Require images
Require video
Listing source
Any
MLS
Non-MLS
Hide with HOA
Hide nearby results
Hide map
Reset
Done
Save
Reset
114 properties
For you
For you
Newest
Price: high to low
Price: low to high
Size: high to low
Size: low to high
Updated
8 months ago
$14,950,000
3.4 acres
Suffolk County
6 bd, 8 ba
•
6,000 sq ft
Shelter Island, NY 11964
2 months ago
$8,750,000
7 acres
Suffolk County
8 bd, 9 ba
•
8,000 sq ft
Shelter Island, NY 11964
9 months ago
$3,600,000
2 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 4 ba
•
3,000 sq ft
Shelter Island, NY 11964
2 years ago
$645,000
1.16 acres
Suffolk County
Shelter Island, NY 11964
37 days ago
$3,600,000
2 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 3 ba
•
2,890 sq ft
Shelter Island, NY 11964
10 months ago
$5,750,000
2.2 acres
Suffolk County
7 bd, 7 ba
•
4,941 sq ft
Shelter Island, NY 11964
39 days ago
$1,850,000
5.5 acres
Suffolk County
1 bd, 1 ba
•
1,800 sq ft
Shelter Island, NY 11964
8 hours
$5,999,000
5.18 acres
Suffolk County
Water Mill, NY 11976
2 months ago
$599,000
0.92 acres
Suffolk County
Southold, NY 11971
5 months ago
$5,995,000
5.6 acres
Suffolk County
6 bd, 8 ba
•
7,200 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
$200k drop • Jan 8
$6,900,000
51 acres
Suffolk County
Peconic, NY 11971
5 months ago
$4,250,000
2.85 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 4 ba
•
3,866 sq ft
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$55k drop • Jan 30
$3,295,000
5 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 3 ba
•
3,000 sq ft
Wainscott, NY 11975
2 months ago
$5,495,000
2.4 acres
Suffolk County
6 bd, 7 ba
•
6,625 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
7 months ago
$5,995,000
7 acres
Suffolk County
7 bd, 8 ba
•
7,178 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
22 days
$10,995,000
5.2 acres
Suffolk County
7 bd, 9 ba
•
10,000 sq ft
Water Mill, NY 11976
$205k drop • Jan 13
$1,995,000
4.27 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 2 ba
•
— sq ft
Southold, NY 11971
$100k drop • Mar 7
$2,749,000
3 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 4 ba
•
2,600 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
15 days
$7,750,000
2.7 acres
Suffolk County
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
8 months ago
$3,750,000
5.72 acres
Suffolk County
East Marion, NY 11939
8 months ago
$3,750,000
5.72 acres
Suffolk County
East Marion, NY 11939
5 months ago
$6,999,000
5.18 acres
Suffolk County
6 bd, 4 ba
•
3,328 sq ft
Water Mill, NY 11976
5 months ago
$4,495,000
2.2 acres
Suffolk County
5 bd, 6 ba
•
5,260 sq ft
Southampton, NY 11968
3 months ago
$19,400,000
3.7 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 5 ba
•
3,802 sq ft
Bridgehampton, NY 11932
6 months ago
$1,750,000
0.37 acres
Suffolk County
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
13 months ago
$6,995,000
6.68 acres
Suffolk County
East Hampton, NY 11937
2 months ago
$32,500,000
2.62 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 5 ba
•
5,500 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
$100k drop • Mar 25
$897,000
0.53 acres
Suffolk County
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
5 months ago
$8,475,000
3.43 acres
Suffolk County
7 bd, 7 ba
•
7,900 sq ft
Bridgehampton, NY 11932
18 months ago
$1,225,000
0.46 acres
Suffolk County
East Hampton, NY 11937
42 days ago
$6,895,000
6 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 2 ba
•
3,962 sq ft
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
10 months ago
$5,500,000
3.7 acres
Suffolk County
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
16 months ago
$3,495,000
4 acres
Suffolk County
Wainscott, NY 11975
2 years ago
$27,500,000
3 acres
Suffolk County
11 bd, 17 ba
•
20,014 sq ft
Sagaponack, NY 11962
$650k drop • Mar 26
$5,995,000
2.5 acres
Suffolk County
7 bd, 9 ba
•
8,500 sq ft
Water Mill, NY 11968
13 days
$5,645,000
6.72 acres
Suffolk County
3 bd, 2 ba
•
1,850 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
5 months ago
$27,083/mo
6 acres
Suffolk County
5,366 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
31 days ago
$1,700,000
5.25 acres
Suffolk County
Southold, NY 11971
5 months ago
$2,750,000
3.5 acres
Suffolk County
3 bd, 3 ba
•
2,000 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
6 months ago
$2,450,000
2.67 acres
Suffolk County
2 bd, 3 ba
•
3,452 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
4 months ago
$2,775,000
3.2 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 2 ba
•
2,200 sq ft
East Marion, NY 11939
2 months ago
$300,000/mo
2.2 acres
Suffolk County
6 bd, 5 ba
•
2,900 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
$180k drop • Jan 11
$3,995,000
2 acres
Suffolk County
6 bd, 6 ba
•
6,100 sq ft
Southampton, NY 11968
14 days
$80,000/mo
2.2 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 4 ba
•
3,000 sq ft
Sagaponack, NY 11962
5 months ago
$1,995,000
0.92 acres
Suffolk County
East Hampton, NY 11937
11 months ago
$2,995,000
7.64 acres
Suffolk County
Sag Harbor, NY 11932
2 days
$12,995,000
2.37 acres
Suffolk County
7 bd, 9 ba
•
8,030 sq ft
North Haven, NY 11963
13 days
$2,875,000
3.14 acres
Suffolk County
East Hampton, NY 11937
13 days
$2,750,000
3.6 acres
Suffolk County
3 bd, 2 ba
•
1,850 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
14 days
$1,995,000
2.17 acres
Suffolk County
East Hampton, NY 11937
1
2
3
1-50 of 114 properties
Map