List

Middle Island, NY cottages for sale

1 property
For you
For you
Newest
Price hi-lo
Price lo-hi
Size hi-lo
Size lo-hi
Updated

Explore land for sale in Middle Island, NY and cottages for sale in New York for more nearby properties.

Buying cottages in Middle Island

Find cottages for sale in Middle Island, NY including country cottage homes, small stone cottages, craftsman-style cottage houses, and lake cottages with land.

There is currently one cottage with land for sale near Middle Island, with a listing price of $798,000. The average cost to buy is $399,000 per acre. Browse land for sale in Middle Island, NY for more properties on the market nearby.

Cottages for sale in Middle Island

Acreage for sale
2 acres
Average listing age
52 days
Average list price
$798,000
Median list price
$798,000
Average property size
2 acres
View map